www.flickr.com
Ross Cleaver's photos More of Ross Cleaver's photos
















coming soon


This Weeks Doctor Who - The Empty Child

MAKE POVERTY HISTORY

INFERNAL DEVICES

UPDATE

EXTERMINATE

Didnt work huh?

Another Short Test Blog

Apple Store

quickie

Ian at the beach


April 2005 May 2005 June 2005 July 2005 August 2005 September 2005 October 2005 November 2005 January 2006 February 2006 March 2006 April 2006 May 2006 June 2006 July 2006 August 2006 September 2006 October 2006 November 2006 December 2006 January 2007 February 2007 August 2007 
























EMAIL ME

ross@rosscleaver.co.uk

iChat me
Talk to me on iChat/AIM

LEAVE ME A MESSAGE

6.09.2005 
REVENGE OF THE SITH

We went to see Star Wars Episode III last night. The more I think about it the more annoyed I am that some thing so badly written and acted could have so much money spent on it and receive so much adoration. But am I being to harsh? Surely it must have some good points... let tally them up shall we:

PRO's
R2D2 - especially at the start of the film R2 was used really well and gave some great laughs, strangely enough for a dustbin on wheel he showed probably the best characterisation in the whole movie.

Special Effects - the computer animation in the film is superb, Yoda (when not jumping around like a loon) looked very plausible as a real 'person' although was no where near Gollum when it comes to 'performance' in a CGi character.

Music - Old School = Ace

Sound Effects - see above

Design - Great all round nice to that that Alderan was the source of the 1970's funky design that seems to have swept the galaxy by the time 'a new hope hope' comes around.

Natalie Portman - looking good as always, but couldn't act for shit in this... but more of that soon...


CONS
Acting - no one except Ewan McGregor seemed to be able to give anything near a decent performance in this, to call them wooden would be the equivalent of calling the great rain forests a bit 'twiggy'. Portman seemed to be reading her dreadful lines off of a piece of cardboard, Ian McDiarmid was auditioning for pantomime (why do villains always find that the best way to express how evil they are is to laugh in a evil kinda way?), Hayden Chistensen was for the lack of any other word... shit, and i couldn't even concentrate on Samuel L Jackson's performance for all the eye popping gurning he was pulling.

Wookies - why? they didn't do anything (expect prove that even in a universe full of millions upon millions of different 'people' everyone knows some one who knows someone)... but strangely the toys shops are full of wookie toys, they cant be cashing in on our love of the original trilogy can they?

Script - the dialogue is THE WORST i have ever heard in a cinema, so lets leave that at that. The Plotting is just over complicated and full of unbelievable turns of events and mistakes, for one Obi Wan starts referring to the senator as 'The Emperor' when he has no way of know that the senator has only just declared him self such.

Anakins Turning - completely unbelievable and stupid

Yoda - "Not if anything I have to say about it, Lord Sidious. At an end your rule is and not short enough it was, I must say. " No More, Say Must I...

Tying up loose ends - we were promised that all the looses ends would be tied up in this move, why was C3PO's memory wiped? what did we get... some guy just decide that is would be a good idea. Why don't the Jedi fade away when they die...because Yoda says Qui Gon* has found a way to come back from the dead a train jedi to do so, but why dont we see a ghostly Liam Neeson? probably because he read the script and though it was pants

Clones/ Storm Troopers - why are they taking their helmets off to show poorly digitally stuck on heads in this movie but not in any subsequent films. Why have they decided that camouflage is no longer an advantage in subsequent films? why have they got names in this film?

Space Travel - Why dose space travel take so long in the IV - VI but everyone one can travel between planets instantaneously in this film?

Light Sabre Battle- to fast and too dark

Why? - why didnt Obi Wan just use the force to push Anakin into the lava to finish him off? !) it would show mercy and but his old friend out of his agony and 2) it would make sure that he was dead and couldn't return

Grievous - why waste time with this stupid piece of product placement? and as for that bird thing obi wan had to ride around!!!!!!!!!!

Length - too long, i was dying for a piss

Best of the trilogy - maybe but if i had to watch any again I would go for phantom menace because at least Liam Neeson can act and the Darth Maul fight was the best thing the whole trilogy (if only they didn't kill him off they could have been hope for these movies)


verdict 4/10 - a big flashly pile of crap thats good to look at until you turn your brain on.

posted by Loop  # 7:27 am
Comments


:


Post a Comment

 



<< Home